Skip to content
Mother’s Helpers Doulas for Greater Boston

Sleep Training Methods Compared: Which One Fits Your Family?

The main sleep training methods, from timed check-ins to staying in the room, how each one works, and how to choose one you can stick with.

By Karen, Certified Postpartum Doula

A swaddled newborn in a knitted hat, sleeping soundly

There’s no single right way to sleep train. Here are the main methods, how each one works, and how to pick one you’ll actually stick with.

Before any method

Every method starts the same way:

  • A bedtime routine in the same order every night
  • Putting your baby down drowsy but awake
  • The ABCs of safe sleep: baby sleeps Alone, on their Back, in a Crib or bassinet

We sleep train babies and children after 6 months old, as long as your pediatrician has said your child no longer needs overnight feeds.

The methods

MethodHow it worksYou stay in the room?
Cry it out (extinction)Put baby down and don’t go back in until morning or the next feedNo
Ferber (timed check-ins)Leave, then check in briefly at waits that grow each time and each nightShort visits
Chair methodSit by the crib, then move the chair farther away every few nightsYes, at first
Pick up put downPick baby up to calm them, put them down awake, repeatYes

Cry it out

The most direct method. You say goodnight and don’t go back in until morning or a planned feed. It can be the quickest, and the hardest for parents to listen to. We do not use this method.

The Ferber method

You leave, then go back in for short, calm check-ins at waits that get a little longer each time and each night. Read our full guide to the Ferber method.

The chair method

You sit in a chair by the crib until your baby falls asleep, then move the chair a little farther away every few nights until you’re out of the room. Gentler, and usually slower.

Pick up put down

When your baby cries, you pick them up to calm them, then put them down awake. You repeat until they fall asleep. Very gentle, and it takes patience.

How to choose

  • Pick what you can do every night. Switching methods partway through is harder on everyone.
  • Think about your home. Room sharing, siblings and thin walls all matter.
  • Agree as a couple first. 2am is not the time to decide.

How we help

Your sleep consultant writes a plan for your family, comes to your home for 3 to 5 nights, 9 hours each, and does the nights for you. Every plan comes with a comprehensive written sleep plan and 2 weeks of text support.

I can not recommend Cayla highly enough. From the first night, it was clear that she was very knowledgeable about infant sleep patterns and gentle sleep training methods. She gave us a customized sleep plan to follow and was clear and thorough with her guidance.

Mariah M

PlanPrice
3 nights, 9 hours each$2,100
4 nights, 9 hours each$2,600
5 nights, 9 hours each$3,100

Sleep consulting can also be done completely by video. See our sleep consulting, when to start sleep training and the 4 month sleep regression.

Call 508-881-2200 or text 508-766-0100.

Related questions

What are the main sleep training methods?

Cry it out (extinction), the Ferber method (timed check-ins), the chair method (staying in the room and moving farther away each night), and pick up put down.

What is the gentlest sleep training method?

Methods where you stay in the room, like the chair method or pick up put down, are usually the gentlest. They often take longer than timed check-ins.

Which sleep training method works fastest?

Methods with less parent involvement, like cry it out or timed check-ins, often show change in the first few nights. The method that works is the one you can stick with every night.

What age can you start sleep training?

We sleep train babies and children after 6 months old, with the ok from your pediatrician that overnight feeds are no longer needed.

Do you need a sleep consultant?

No, but many families find it much easier with someone in the house doing the nights for them. Our sleep consultants come to your home for 3 to 5 nights, or work with you by video.

Want to talk it through?

Call, text or send a note.